Post

Conversation

David Watson ๐Ÿฅ‘
Post your reply

If you don't recognize and call the Gaza genocide a genocide, which it is, then you're no more left-wing than someone denying the Holcaust is/was one
Square profile picture
Launch products now and grow your business with X Ads. โ€™s NEO robot campaign shows how X can turn a product announcement into action. As put it, X was the perfect launch platform.
The media could not be played.
Imo there is a lot of variation about Gaza in the candidates that donโ€™t get reduced to โ€œgenocideโ€. Talarico has committed to a ban on offensive weapons sale. Thatโ€™s more left wing than most senators in congress
There is zero distinction between โ€œleft-wingโ€ Democrat and โ€œestablishmentโ€ Democrat, apart from the speed at which they reveal their true intentions
Image
Quote
skepticalifornia
@skepticaliblog
Itโ€™s important to realize that there is now *zero* daylight between the most lunatic fringe DSA commie and the โ€œestablishmentโ€ Democrats now on this issue This is Bloombergโ€™s anointed (and lavishly purchased) candidate for New Yorkโ€™s 12th Congressional District He is advocating x.com/MicahLasher/stโ€ฆ
The area where the progressives seem to have won, at least rhetorically, is "going after the oligarchs/corporations/techlords" - you should put a column in for something like that.
So what makes someone a moderate is how much they support Gaza genocide? Lol Talarico supports universal healthcare
Climate/Green New Deal, although I donโ€™t think that issue galvanizes the DSA/far left crowd anymore (esp when ranked with Abolish ICE, Gaza)
Another difference among them is moderate ones are cowards. If they truly differ in policy they are silent, so Iโ€™m not sure they actually believe differently, or are just wiser and donโ€™t open their mouths.
SCOTUS packing/โ€œreformโ€ should be on this list. Also Abolish ICE seems to be the demand of even moderate lib pundits these days so not sure your second column reflects reality.
Woke/DEI issues are another one. These now toxic ideologies arose in Left-dominated universities and destroyed them, their intellectual freedom and speech, diversity of viewpoints. Talarico cleverly calls out Woke, trans and academia. Newsom said this.
Quote
Kaiz ๐Ÿ‚๐Ÿ€„๏ธ
@Kaiz_294
James Talarico responds to AOC calling woke 1.0 crazy, policing people's language is performative politics, and it stops you from building a coalition โ€œI do think that there was a rise in performative politics in people who are more concerned about using the right words, usually
The media could not be played.
lol the โ€œmoderateโ€ dem position on healthcare is to do essentially nothing beyond than restore ACA subsidies. But itโ€™s good that the left has had so much influence on intra-party healthcare discussion that public option and Medicare age drop are now ceded as โ€œmoderateโ€ in debate.
Matt, Troy Jackson is the only one that comes off as progressive out of those listed. The rest are some variation of Centrist/Moderate/Pragmatic, with some economic populism thrown in wrt Brown and Turek.
Mostly agree with this but Annie Andrews was close to a generic Dem and did very well--Darline Graham surely a terrible candidate but her performance was very surprising to me
honestly the only one i really support here is the fossil fuel transition like just build nuclear we dont need gas for anything but cars and occasional home heating anymore its not OUR fault communists are too stupid to boil water
Image
Ooooh let me pick the 6 random prog litmus tests: -packing SCOTUS -term limits -Robinhood wealth redistribution -no more unnecessary wars -DC statehood -filibuster reform
Seems fair and accurate Iow, different positions for their very different states, which is fine The trick will be for the 2028 nominee to find the sweet spot
Is this just for the โ€˜26 election? Sherrod Brown has called himself progressive for years. He wrote a whole book about progressivism.
excluding Troy Jackson bc Maine is weird, who is the most โ€œleftistโ€ candidate based on this table and how did they perform relative to other candidates in terms of Trump margin to 2026 margin
Arbitrary. These are positions on a continuum and need to be measured accordingly. A key lesson from this election and from research on categories is that these categories are fuzzy and binary variables do not capture the variety of positions along these dimensions.