Post

Conversation

Jensen Huang reportedly instructed his team at Nvidia "never to think about" planning for a Taiwan contingency. Despite the fact that their business is reliant on TSMC. The Jensen-Megaspeed mess really puts these incredible — and barely-noticed — details from Stephen Witt's The Thinking Machine in a new light: Huang refuses to consider the impact on his global business if China were to blockade or invade Taiwan, despite the regular threats emanating from Beijing to do just that. “To my great surprise, Nvidia had done no contingency planning for this eventuality,” Witt writes. He quotes Deb Shoquist, Nvidia’s executive vice-president of operations: “If something happens to Taiwan and TSMC, the ramifications are so large it’s almost like asking me what I’d do if California fell into the ocean.” Huang had instructed her “never to think about this question.” —from my essay earlier this year on Nvidia and American policy toward China: nybooks.com/articles/2026/ —more thoughts from me today: juliangewirtz.substack.com/p/does-jensen-
David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

Ah, thank you. I’ve read the book, but it was more than a year ago, and I can’t recall this passage. (even so, quite a massive topic to not come up in the recent (pre-scandal) barrage of interviews).
China would not invade Taiwan; even if it did, there would be no contingency measures within Nvidia's control.
Jensen Huang is right about this. Those are just threats and will never happen.
What did he say that is incorrect? RAND and other analyses have concluded there are essentially no good short-term options if Taiwan production is cut off; the economic impact would be severe for years. This is such a ridiculous take
This is nuts. Shareholders should be furious. Even if there is a 1% chance (and honestly it’s much higher for disruption of some kind). Depending. The de write.. the damage to the company would be irreversible. Company ending. He knows that if he were to say commit to moving towards Intel. He would lessen his home countries relevance over time. He’s willing to sacrifice everything to assure Taiwan is forever safe. He needs to go.
中国太危险了,英伟达最好赶紧开辟一条产线生产厕纸和洗手液吧——这样才能确保英伟达不受任何“中国产品”威胁。
He's probably right here...So many people want to put effort into things that just make them feel better. Investing in this actually would increase the likelihood of success for the company and be a cost.
Actually Jensen Sounds quite reasonable here, and like someone who is hell bent to make an issue out of nothing. The contingency plan for if Tiwan fell will have to be at the national & international level and not company level. What Trump was doing by getting TSMC to invest in Arizona was the right move (along with bringing Memory manufacturing). Jensen was highly supportive of tat. Also, GPUs last 7-8 years. There are plenty of them (20M of them) in operation already. US ecosystem already has nearly 20 times more AI compute compared to China. It is quite ridiculous, how sane judgements are being used against him. What do you expect him to do at individual level , can you spell out?
Image
Who is telling you Jensen Huang failed to plan for a Taiwan war? Julian Gewirtz. Senior Director for China and Taiwan at the Biden White House. Taiwan crisis planning was his portfolio. Not Nvidia’s. His. Now he is out of government, blaming a chip company for not doing his old job. His own administration’s answer to Taiwan risk was the CHIPS Act: bring TSMC to Arizona. Nvidia did exactly that. April 2025: Blackwell production begins at TSMC Arizona. October 2025: the first American-made Blackwell wafer. Up to $500 billion of AI infrastructure to be built in the U.S. By his own government’s standard, that is the plan. So what is this post really for? An affair. A customer accused of smuggling. A book anecdote about Taiwan. Nothing connects them except one sentence: “puts these details in a new light.” Place two unrelated stories side by side, say nothing, and let the reader connect the dots. A former White House official knows exactly what that does. Read the quote he picked. If Taiwan and TSMC go, “it’s almost like asking me what I’d do if California fell into the ocean.” That’s not negligence. It’s the truth: no company can hedge a war. Apple, AMD, Qualcomm and Broadcom all depend on TSMC. He hasn’t tweeted about them. The sourcing: a journalist writes that one executive says Huang told her. In his tweet, that becomes “his team.” The timing: “From my essay earlier this year.” “More thoughts from me today.” An old argument, hitched to a new scandal. Substack link included. So say it plainly, Mr. Gewirtz. What new light? Recklessness? Argue it. Loyalty? Prove it. You held the Taiwan portfolio. You don’t get to hint.
This is reasonable from Jensen. Nvidia is a private company and TSMC is too large of a risk to contingency plan by a private company. TSMC is a national scale risk that should be addressed by the fed gov with consultation from the private sector. I'm from a top 5 insurer and we don't get into the infrastructure, utility ,FEMA, and army corp of engineer side of things during a risk & contingency planning. This is the same.
At the risk of doing a "ya gotta hand it to 'em..." There are things that are borderline pointless to speculate about, but which can utterly consume teams minds. Part of a leader's job is getting people to focus on what's in their control.
To be fair. 52% of all chips on the planet are produced by TSMC. It's difficult to conceptualize contingency planning for that. Also China taking Taiwan is a western hemisphere multi-country contingency problem, not any one company's to fully figure out per game theory.
He's not wrong. Do you know how many monopolies are in the GPU supply chain? Most of them are in Asia. In such a war, nothing from Korea, Japan or the island of Taiwan will make to the US. And you can forget about getting chokepoints from China into the US.
that’s so true. people question this because they don’t understand AI chips industry as well as China. There is no contingency plan if China invades Taiwan. are you going to fight against China for Taiwan?
If China blockades or invades Taiwan, taking TSMC's output off the market will open up the opportunity for other companies that have the basic technology but have not been able to compete w/ TSMC on price. Prices would then be somewhat higher, and availability lower, for a while
Lol. All AVGO XPU & AMD chips are built in Taiwan. So they should go to Intel? If thats so Intel stock price wont be below 60 now.