Post

Conversation

The argument I made in 2024 was that Trump wouldn't be able to end the war, because while he'd have a lot of leverage over Ukraine in theory, in practice he wouldn't be able to use it because if he tried it would cause a massive backlash in the US and the political cost would just not be worth it. To be honest, I think I had underestimated how much personal antipathy Trump had for Zelensky and the Ukrainians in general, but I think the way in which nobody is willing to own the decision to cut Ukraine off from Starlink and it had to reversed almost immediately is a good illustration of what I was talking about. Conversely, Trump could in theory induce the Russians to compromise by promising to deliver on some of the things they care about (such as sanctions or the European security architecture), but in practice he can't because he'd need the support of Congress and US allies for that and they will never go along with that. So they will just see it through.
Quote
Joe Barnes
@Barnes_Joe
EXCLUSIVE: Elon Musk came to Donald Trump with the plan to throttle Ukraine’s use of SpaceX’s Starshield satellite internet network, sources have told the Telegraph. The tech billionaire made the proposal during the US President’s row with Volodymyr Zelensky over strikes on
David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

Musk only realizing the economic fallout afterwards is telling (EU will dump the system/be in the process of dumping it Musk pulled shit like this), i doubt Trump even knew it was possible beforehand to put a speed limit on the thing.
While your topline is correct, the reasoning is not. Not many people in the US would actually care if Trump pulled out, literally no one talks about the Ukraine war. However, the EU and UK care very, very much and our media cares a lot what they think. It's very curious that
Square profile picture
The next generation Starlink V5 has a smaller form factor and lightweight design with greater power efficiency. With speeds up to 375+ Mbps, Starlink V5 delivers reliable home internet for streaming, video calling, gaming and more. Available in select areas.
It is telling how terrified Trump and Elon are about what they did here. This is going to be a huge story for a long time.
I honestly don’t see how the Russians are willing to compromise. Their outward rhetoric and internal discourse have been quite consistent and also their actions point towards maximalist goals (which are obviously unreachable but Putin doesn’t care)
Trump never had the leverage to force Ukraine to surrender. No US President would, unless he want to go to war against Ukraine.
Same here. After Zelensky refused to cave to him after that disaster meeting at the WH, I realized Trump would bluff and feing, but would never accept being labeled the guy who lost Ukraine.
He should have applied the leverage as soon as he took office. Doing it at his weakest and most vulnerable moment is ineffective.
Another thing is ,the British are well known propagandists The Telegraph guy is probably lying too,what they are claiming , probably never happened
Russians have given Trump a chance to force peace deal for over a year and he failed. Now, they will just move on with their own plan to collapse Ukraine and then reaproach Trump with much stronger position at the end of 2027.
The whole war is so stupid at this point , and should be brought to an end The Ukrainian Army doesn't look like the can take back the areas presently occupied by Russian forces even in the next two years Flying drones into refineries in Russia makes for good headlines though
He could do it if he had moved fast at the beginning of this term but he was distracted by DOGE, tariff wars and ultimately the fake "Ukraine rare earths deal". It's easy to distract an old person, especially when the whole US and EU political class is preoccupied with it.
The political cost of abandoning Ukraine proved harder to manage than the campaign rhetoric suggested, especially with congressional and public backlash looming