Post

Conversation

They replaced clean nuclear with some of the dirtiest coal in the world
Quote
Epic Maps ๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ
@theepicmap
Why is Germany's air quality so much worse than it's neighboring countries?
Image
258.6K
Views
David Watson ๐Ÿฅ‘
Post your reply

Germany is such a badly managed country, one of the worst in the world. Pathetic.
What an utterly moronic post. At least include the time to let people very when this was. Yesterday we had 35ยฐC + across Germany during an intense heatwave which now shifted eastward. Heatwaves are linked to increasing Ozone (O3) levels which are the main driver here
Image
Image
Image
"But but Nuclear energy will not solve the climate crisis long term๐Ÿ˜ขโ€œ But burning coal will? It was an irrational decision by Merkel after Fukushima. That is what German politics has become. Realpolitik died. Now its emotion and ideology.
It's a momentary snapshot. I'd hazard a guess that it's due to high ozone levels in the heat wave this week. AQI is based on: ground-level ozone, particle pollution, carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide.
The coal plants have filters and don't cause a lot of PM2.5 or nitrogen oxide pollution. You just picked out a bad day. A few hours later has Italy covered all in red for bad air quality and most of Germany in green:
Image
While the coal problem is real, this seems to be a momentary snapshot of "air quality right now", and not a long-term view, which looks more like this:
Image
If that was the case, the air in Poland would be much worse as it is a smaller country burning more lignite. But geez, even the fact that there was a lot more lignite in Germany when the NPPs where still around is already too much for you...
I find it interesting how the "nuclear bad because durr spill" types have never considered the constant pollution of every fossil fuel. News flash, coal waste can spill and be toxic too! Nuclear shit doesn't magically explode. The average normie is so terrified & propagandized
1. This is a lucky guess. a) coal is a problem,but ๐Ÿ‡ฉ๐Ÿ‡ช has renewables, too. b) ๐Ÿ‡ฉ๐Ÿ‡ช is densely populated,eg ๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ท has far more nature plus the sea 2. We should not take every map on X for the best scientific result. I googled air polution in Europe and found a lot of different maps.
Image
Image
Image
Image
No, they didn't replace nuclear with coal. Germany historically relied a lot on coal for electricity, but that has steadily declined over time. Still remains too high. And nuclear could have been pushed untile the end of its operational life.
Image
Doesn't seem plausible to me. The Northern Rhineland region between Cologne, Aachen and Dรผsseldorf is green on this map though it has the highest density of lignite power plants while the strongest red is around Frankfurt where you won't find any carbon plant.
Somebody has to create electricity after French and Swiss nuclear power stations can't. Because rivers get too hot for cooling. Happens almost every summer, now. And wait for it: the summer has just begun. Will be much worse in August or so.
Quote
Frรคulein Nass
@jenny_nass26
Und wieder sind die ร–kos dran schuld ๐Ÿ˜ 
Image
During WWI, German warships kept a stock of British coal on board for combat, because the German coal was so dirty that burning it would clog the boilers.
It's dubious at that time of the year and seeing that's not the case in Poland ' so probably more due to local meteorological conditions
Of all things, I am surprised that the Green (as in Nuclear) Scare is still having a decisive impact on governance.
Chernobyl created a significant political backlash against nuclear energy and many countries avoided investing in it, so Angela and many others preferred to switch to Russian gas...what followed is clearly visible.
Germany succeeded since WW2 despite the horrible management not because of it. Sometimes air quality is just linked to high traffic
ร‰ pq o povo cismava de ficar viajando no tempo perto das usinas, moh B.O.
Image
How is nuclear clean? Is the extraction of uranium clean? Also costs a lot more and because of the heatwave France and Switzerland had to shut some down.
Could you please explain the pristine air quality in Poland and Serbia, if they both have *even worse* numbers regarding dirty coal energy production than Germany? How does that add up if the air quality is a consequence of the energy production from coal, as you suggested?
Passa com la plana de Vic, รฉs allร  on va tota la merda que es genera a Barcelona i Tarragona. Tambรฉ potser รฉs efecte dela รบltims incendis.
Absolutely not what happened. Both fossil and nuclear energy sources were replaced with renewables over the last decade. Coal power plants are being shut down with most being gone by 2035.
Yeah there is also stuff thats called traffic (looks like Germany is somehow in the middle of Europe?) and industry and an Air Quality Index (of an random time) is a mix of many pollution sources.
Until today there is no sustainable solution for nuclear waste. So how is nuclear energy clean?
Bullshit. The yellow is not at all where the coal power plants are. And anyhow pollution from car tires has certainly a higher impact on air quality.
We have burning woods right now in Germany. The electricity is covered around 70% by renewables and coal plants arenโ€™t necessarily big polluters. For all the good takes you make, itโ€™s always bullshit regarding nuclears with you.
Brilliant to shut down cheap and secure energy sources to demand war projects. I see no flaw in the German government's lodge. They were left with cognitive aftereffects from COVID. ๐Ÿ˜…๐Ÿ˜…๐Ÿ˜…
GIF
This is just an obvious motivated lie and propaganda. Noone "replaced nuclear with coal". The truth is: Nuclear phased out and the % of coal in the energy mix declined at the same time. Properly clean sources like wind and solar make up about 50% of electricity production now.
Sit this one out. You clearly don't know anything about the history of the German energy sector and the politics behind it.
So by 2029, 40 years after the fall of The Wall, the unification will have resulted in the economy and environmental pollution of the DDR throughout Germany. Who won?
Still insane to me such an engineered minded country like Germany being so suicidally againist nuclear for no real reason while claiming to be so pro environment
The biggest mistake the west made was allowing Germany to continue to exist after WW2. Should have wiped out Germany and Germans
We burn less coal than ever before after shutting down the nuclear plants WTF is this tweet? Youโ€™re supposed to be a journalist
Image
We burnt 69% coal day and night when 36 reactors could produce only 31% of Germany's electricity needs in the 1990s. Yesterday we burnt only 21% coal despite having NOT A SINGLE atomic reactor on grid. Why are you kids lying? ๐Ÿคทโ€โ™‚๏ธ
Image