Post

Conversation

David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

The first secret is in problem selection. I focused on problems mathematicians already cared about, especially ones actively discussed by people like Terence Tao. I then used AI to filter out problems that seemed extremely difficult or were closely tied to major open
Each prompt: • restates the problem precisely, • specifies what a complete proof or disproof must establish, • lists weaker results that do not count, • identifies problem-specific traps and edge cases, • requires independent adversarial agents to challenge every candidate
The prompt also tells the system how to manage the search: • start with many independent approaches, • keep several incompatible routes alive, • search aggressively for counterexamples to proposed lemmas, • mark a route as blocked if it only reduces the problem to another
The third secret is model selection. I used GPT-5.6 Sol with Ultra reasoning effort. Compared with earlier models, it was effective across a much wider range of problems and much better at sustaining long, rigorous mathematical searches.
I then pasted the prompt into Codex, set it as the goal, and let it run. The reason is that Codex can work for long periods, retain the full research context, and use local files with no further interaction needed. You need to be patient and give it enough time to explore. Some
The process was a continual research loop: attempt → failure → diagnosis → new approach → proof draft → adversarial audit → repair The model repeatedly abandoned broken ideas, attacked its own arguments, and strengthened the proof until it could no longer find substantive
Two problems already have complete Lean formalizations, posted and verified correct. Key lemmas for the other four are also formalized in Lean and pass AI verification. I can’t claim full rigor on the remaining proofs yet, but I’ll finish all Lean proofs soon.
I would guess that there are more than enough papers written as puzzles to solve these but nobody had the capacity to go through them all. Which makes the AI very valuable