Post

Conversation

I'm perennially confused that teachers unions aren't advocates for this, it seems like an obvious scenario where there is zero conflict between the public interest and the interests of the workforce and yet if anything they are opposed.
David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

Teachers’ unions as a whole prioritize equity. Tracking can improve top-end outcomes but can also stratify—and the unions fear that disadvantaged communities will be locked into lower strata.
Teachers unions these days care a lot more about left wing politics than their working conditions.
I’d guess part of the issue is that it’s unpleasant and stressful to divide up children by abilities and then to explain to mom and dad why their kid isn’t in the smart group.
Grouping kids by age, passing them along no matter what, teaching them all the exact same thing, and having them sit quietly in rows for hours at a time while doing it seems bad.
One difficulty is there aren't enough teachers to execute in this manner. Let's look at the complete picture. We would need enough teachers for two per class. Then enough to rotate them through the students. The teachers must remain fresh. Federal direct funding is necessary.
Show additional replies, including those that may contain offensive content