Post

Conversation

Aaron Reichlin-Melnick
@ReichlinMelnick
KEY TAKEAWAY: Supreme Court is UNANIMOUS in requiring due process: - Roberts majority: Trump admin MUST give notice and time to challenge in court. - Kavanaugh concurrence: Judicial review available - Sotomayor dissent: All 9 agree deportations without due process are illegal
Image
Image
Image
Quote
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick
@ReichlinMelnick
IMPORTANT: Sotomayor, in the dissent, emphasizes that all 9 justices believe that the Trump administration cannot do what it wants to do: shove people onto a plane with no due process at all. They openly told the DC Circuit they were going to do that if they won. No review. x.com/adeferr/status…
Show more
291.2K
Views
David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

chris berdos 🛻🏕
@jazzynaturist
was assured in “SCOTUS upholds trump’s use of alien enemies act” that it was some huge MAGA win guess not 😂 sure any POTUS can use the law but they have to secure the receipts (which doubt trump even knows how to do that)
758
P.T. Ward
@HTWardish
Key takeaway: Judge Boasberg did not have jurisdiction and class certification no longer applies because not eligible in habeas.
3.5K
Tammy88 🇺🇲 🇺🇦
@tr26764
Confused. What is Sotomayor dissenting from? The majority ruled in favor of due process.
2.6K
Brandon
@Studio89_Design
Not good enough...but the best we're going to get. Supreme Court could've checked the power of the Executive right there....and didn't.
445
Gwenn Hibbs
@gwennlee
Lawyer here. But by using the shadow docket to dictate habeas filings in Texas (& so endorse implicitly the regime’s bad faith conduct so far), the majority consign all the deportees now in El Salvador’s to CECOT hell-on-earth indefinitely.
660
conomarz
@conomarz
Why doesn’t the court address all the actual issues of the case? Why did they feel they needed to rule in 5 seconds rather than have an actual hearing?
2K
shadowhikari
@shadowhikari2
So this is another Korematsu situation: the government is acting illegally in our opinion BUT we feel completely powerless to stop them so….illegal acts get to happen.
463
Mike
@MikeD9111
So what about the ppl they already did this to? Can the Goverment be ordered to bring tham all back and start over?
511
Les Le M🌎n ✒ DEFEND DEMOCRACY! Auth🌎r 💻
@LesLeMonAuthor
No one's reading the fine print, or even the medium print 47 and his minions see this as carte blanc, and will continue to dissappear a random melange of people w/ out due diligence or due process, or obligation to return any wrongfully deported individuals Unfathomable
84
notthecommish
@Notrhecommish
So if their lawyers can show a lack of any due process in the Texas court system is there a chance they could win since the Supreme Court agrees they deserve due process?
447
Vince
@GenXVince
Folks, beware the headlines. SCOTUS hasn’t ruled the Alien Enemies Act constitutional for peacetime. They just allowed deportations to proceed for now while the courts figure it out. Big difference.
2K
Cos ras
@Cosras1
stop calling him a justice and call him what he really is a "FACIST FACILITATOR"
429
Texian
@Texian70
Can someone in this thread explain how you give 10 million+ Illegals an hearing( due process)….if the average hearing is 30 minutes, that comes out to almost 570 years
49
Draic74
@draic74
So if an immigration judge rules that an illegal should be deported and gives final orders as such, does that count as due process? Or do they get another round of appeals outside the immigration court system?
1.3K
Bella Ross
@BellaRo36233586
And the majority also agreed that the Democrats can’t do what they are doing - forum shopping for activist liberal DC judges to get the unconstitutional outcome they want.
15
CwCage🇺🇸🇯🇵🇮🇪🇺🇸
@CC_Bombay
Since your ilk opposes you should be saddled with the responsibility of housing and administering all “humane” necessities until further adjudicating is complete.
599
Alibar
@AlizapeBar
Why didn’t all 9 agree that allowing millions to enter our country, in flagrant violation of the law, without notice and due process for the American people, i.e. checking who they are and why they’re here, was illegal? Because it wasn’t politically convenient. We are a country
134
The Real Everybody
@realeverybody
Quote
Megyn Kelly
@megynkelly
BREAKING: Supreme Court by 5-4 decision lifts restraining order against Trump admin & takes Venezuelan deportee case away from Judge Boasberg (improper venue - the ACLU forum shopped). Says detainees entitled to some measure of due process but in the venue where they were held:
Show more
391
Sludge Pit
@NewtonWombat
So in removing the alleged TdA members to El Salvador without giving them ANY notice or opportunity for judicial review, the Trump regime knowingly and deliberately violated the Constitution. They knew at the time it was illegal, and they did it anyway.
71
Hunter
@hunterx2764
What’s funny is like Dems hand picking judges and courts, Republicans will do the same and call it “due process” and be within the ruling for deportation. This stops nothing
40