Post

Conversation

19% of Americans have a positive opinion of Luigi Mangione, 61% have a negative opinion
Image
Quote
Ramesh Ponnuru
@RameshPonnuru
I'm sorry we're in this position, but I think it would be helpful for some pollster to test the extent to which Mangione is a "folk hero," people think his actions were understandable, etc.
David Watson 🥑
Post your reply

Quote
Center for Strategic Politics
@StratPolitics
BREAKING: In First Poll Since Killing, Young Americans Favor Luigi Mangione over UnitedHealthcare & Slain CEO Brian Thompson Youth have a higher net approval of Mangione (-10%) than of Brian Thompson (-24%), UnitedHealthcare (-31%), and the health insurance industry (-34%).
Show more
Image
Corrected graphic
Quote
Center for Strategic Politics
@StratPolitics
Replying to @StratPolitics
CORRECTION: The second and third graphics included mistakenly swapped somewhat negative and strong negative bars. Corrected graphics below:
Image
Image
Quote
Center for Strategic Politics
@StratPolitics
BREAKING: In First Poll Since Killing, Young Americans Favor Luigi Mangione over UnitedHealthcare & Slain CEO Brian Thompson Youth have a higher net approval of Mangione (-10%) than of Brian Thompson (-24%), UnitedHealthcare (-31%), and the health insurance industry (-34%).
Show more
Image
Still a higher net approval than the dead CEO, UHC and the whole healthcare industry among under 45
Quote
Center for Strategic Politics
@StratPolitics
BREAKING: In First Poll Since Killing, Young Americans Favor Luigi Mangione over UnitedHealthcare & Slain CEO Brian Thompson Youth have a higher net approval of Mangione (-10%) than of Brian Thompson (-24%), UnitedHealthcare (-31%), and the health insurance industry (-34%).
Show more
Image
How is it possible that 42% of the total sample answered “strong negative”, but only 28% of the under 45 portion and 16% of the 45+? It isn’t. Something is fishy with the presentation of the data.
Quote
Center for Strategic Politics
@StratPolitics
Replying to @StratPolitics
CORRECTION: The second and third graphics included mistakenly swapped somewhat negative and strong negative bars. Corrected graphics below:
Image
Image
that datapoint, the 68k, actually comes from a study that tried to model how many people would die every year if Obamacare *had not passed*, just fyi
Quote
Yair Rosenberg
@Yair_Rosenberg
Replying to @Yair_Rosenberg
You will rarely go wrong betting on this point: theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/
Image
You have been selected to participate in Hillsdale College’s National Opinion Survey on Critical Race Theory in American education. Your opinion as an informed patriot is critical to help us respond to this crisis. Please start your survey using the secure link below.
It's karmically equivalent to a Trump vote; a tacit endorsement of a crime that will crumble society when copied. Scold them to watch them dig in.
Quote
Dhan
@direfull
A perfect example of people trusting something online just because of a neat graph and a logo – this "think tank" just spawned into existence and this is the only research on their website. I cannot find any information about them elsewhere. Not even on their director's LinkedIn. x.com/ArmandDoma/sta…
Image
Image
Ya, this is folk hero level. We might be cooked. We already had a problem with folks shooting others for notoriety and attention. Now folks are getting positive attention. Get ready for random acts of violence go up.
astonishing that 31% of people under 45 have a positive opinion of him. who are these people and how do we rid our society of people who support execution style murders?
Somewhat negative for killing a person among boomers is basically a folk hero for them. Who could be fully supportive? The fact it isn't total condemnation shows the public's hatred for these companies/system
I swear to God just give this kid life or death penalty and get this shit out of the media. It's over, he's some psycho piece of shit who got caught and who's life is over. Stop letting these internet larpers get their rocks off with their weirdo political fantasies.
Would love to see the overlay of this with the people who think Hamas is good, schools should be closed, masks should have stayed on and the riots were mostly peaceful.
Oh wow. They did a poll on who is or isn’t a Luigi Mangione stan? We try people in the justice system not the court of public opinion and execution isn’t legal. Maybe they should do one on the Unabomber or some other serial killer next?
That is a brand new pollster with only a couple posts on their page, and there’s likely a pressure towards claiming to have a negative opinion because who’s telling a stranger on the phone that they support assassinations? Take this poll with a mountain of salt.
Image
"Youth have a higher net approval of Mangione (-10%) than of Brian Thompson (-24%), UnitedHealthcare (-31%), and the health insurance industry (-34%)." this is important context
You have been selected to participate in Hillsdale College’s National Opinion Survey on Critical Race Theory in American education. Your opinion as an informed patriot is critical to help us respond to this crisis. Please start your survey using the secure link below.
I think it's responsible to note that this from a patreon account with a single post. You should at least note that this is not a typical polling source Charts go viral on the internet and stick around long after they're debunked due to overconfident presentation
The most interesting split (to me) is the "strong" - one way or the other 46% of those under 45 have a strong opinion, split 18% strong positive, 28% strong negative Only 19% over 45 do, split 3% strong positive, 16% strong negative.
I'm sorry sir, clearly you've missed this very important scientific study on the matter.
Image
I don’t think this is an interesting question though. My sense is that most people don’t approve of gunning a guy down so think Luigi is bad, but also hate the insurance industry and don’t particularly care that Brian Thompson died
Maybe I don't understand basic math but how does under 45 have a 28% strong disapproval, over 45 have a 16% strong disapproval, and that equates to a total 42% strong disapproval
I thought this caution deserved weight.
Quote
Joey Politano 🏳️‍🌈
@JosephPolitano
Sorry to be the one to pull this card but I have basically zero trust for the results of a poll done by a bunch of inexperienced people who contracted out to Pollfish and picked an obviously highly attention seeking topic to launch their new “think tank” x.com/armanddoma/sta…
Due to the small sample size and because data was collected using Random Device Engagement (RDE) method, it’s likely there was a significant amount of self-selection bias. I’d wager the people who opted in to provide survey data on “random” platforms do not generalize well.
You have been selected to participate in Hillsdale College’s National Opinion Survey on Critical Race Theory in American education. Your opinion as an informed patriot is critical to help us respond to this crisis. Please start your survey using the secure link below.
Some questions about the poll. What locations are the people that are sampled at?, how many of each age group?, how does this poll represent ALL Americans across the country?
How can the total for "Strongly Negative" (42%) be larger than the share saying "Strongly Negative" in each subcategory (28% and 16%)? I must be misreading this.
This survey contacted under 500 people. I don’t think that’s statistically significant to sample and assume this is legit what the entire country thinks. 61% of under 500 people reported this
I'm unsure why Strong Negative is 42% overall despite being only 28% and 16% of the two subsets, or how 19 and 61 average out to 19 for Somewhat Negative.
How is the total-population proportion for "strong negative" greater than both of the proportions of the presumably-exclusive subpopulations under-45 and 45+?
You have been selected to participate in Hillsdale College’s National Opinion Survey on Critical Race Theory in American education. Your opinion as an informed patriot is critical to help us respond to this crisis. Please start your survey using the secure link below.
It’s unclear how they get that overall strong negative number based on the over and under 45 strong negative numbers